.

Letter to the Editor: A Former Judge Rotenberg Center Worker Speaks Out

Greg Miller worked for the Rotenberg Center in Canton for three years and speaks about his experience.

Warning: Some of the content in this letter may be disturbing. Reader discretion is advised.

By Greg Miller

There is so much for me to share about my three years of experience as a staff in that I wanted to share them in writing.

Please note that other former JRC teachers and staff and even psychologists have contacted me in the past to tell me that they appreciate my speaking on behalf of the students, and to tell me of legal threats that keep them from speaking out vocally against JRC’s practices.  I can share only my own experiences and opinions.  No doubt JRC has attempted to discredit me and what I have to share.

My Background

I worked for the for over three years, between 2003 – 2006.  I worked as a Teacher’s Assistant, and I turned down offers to work at JRC as a classroom teacher because I was too busy with my studies. 

I have a Master’s Degree in Elementary Education from Lesley University.  I previously taught as a classroom teacher in Watertown Public Schools, Lincoln Public Schools, and Winchester Public Schools.  I worked too many hours as a classroom teacher to be able to also study alternative medical approaches for the treatment of children with learning difficulties and autism, and JRC offered me an opportunity to continue to work with children and youth while putting myself through school with ideal work hours.

The reason why I remained at JRC for three years instead of leaving on my first day of training was that I liked JRC’s commitment to getting students off of psychiatric drugs. Students were arriving at JRC looking very drugged up and in very rough conditions. I was a very dedicated worker and supporter of JRC at the start of my employment. JRC always treated me fairly as an employee.

Then my opinion of JRC started to change significantly to where I felt I needed to leave JRC and to speak out against its practices. I started to get signs of traumatic stress while working at JRC, and my doctor advised me repeatedly that I should leave JRC for my own health reasons. I became more aware of what was actually happening to individual students at JRC that parents were not permitted to see, and I wondered how many parents would actually be supportive of JRC if they saw what was happening to their children as I did.

My Opinion on the Use of JRC Shock Therapy

I believe that are harmful not only to the student receiving a shock, but to all other students in the room witnessing the traumatic shock incidences. Electric shocks are not necessary to help JRC’s population of students. I saw much use of electric shocks that I felt were unwarranted to appear in student plans, and it seemed to me that individualized student plans were designed without proper oversight or adequate safeguards to prevent misuse of the shock devices. 

I was having signs of traumatic stress including nightmares, night sweats, and elevated blood pressure, so that my doctor advised me that I needed to leave JRC. So imagine what it is like and what harm is being done to students who are actually on electric shock devices, who are committing no "wrong" behaviors, but who must witness their classmates getting shocked all day long!

I have witnessed the traumatic effects of electric shocks not only on the students receiving shocks, but also on other students in the room witnessing the shock “treatments” even though they have exhibited no behaviors. It was not uncommon to have incidences where I would reach for my pencil in my JRC apron pocket, on which hung the remote controls, to have students crying out and or jumping up, or throwing their task up in the air, and even grabbing me, because they thought I was going to shock them. 

These were all behaviors that would cause students to be shocked depending on the individual student’s plan, so groups of students would all get shocked together, all out of their reaction of fear due to myself or another staff reaching for a pencil in our pockets. If any staff chose not to shock students at such times, we would immediately lose our jobs for “refusing to follow student plans.”

I have participated as required in following student plans to shock multiple students, including when they reacted to watching a fellow classmate tied up in a restraint chair getting attacked by a staffer with a plastic knife (being held) to the student’s throat. This was a judge-approved Clockwork-Orange-type “treatment” for a student who swallowed a small X-Acto knife blade.  A staffer, according to the plan, would run up to the student who had all four limbs tied all day long to a restraint chair, and pretend to force a plastic knife down the student’s mouth while another staff pressed the remote control to give a shock to the student. The staff would repeatedly yell in a gruff voice, “Do you want to swallow a knife?” 

Sometimes a number of students watching this would act out in fear and receive shocks for jumping out of their seat, crying out, or dumping their task in reaction to the violence. I highly doubt that the judge ordered all 40 plus other students in the same classroom to have to watch this violent “treatment” of their classmate with his arms and legs tied to a chair. This took place day after day for weeks, with their classmate unable to defend himself in any kind of way. I felt nauseated just being in the room during those treatments, and I was not one of the humans with electric shock devices strapped to my body, so I could only imagine what the students were going through.

I have witnessed terrible injuries including bloody scabs all over the torso, arms, and legs caused by the electrodes. While I have heard of Dr. Israel previously claiming that the injuries were due to staff not properly rotating electrodes after shocking a student, the reality was that some students exhibited behaviors resulting in up to 30 shocks in a day. Some students stopped their behaviors after receiving their maximum 30 shocks for the day. Most of the shock devices used two electrodes to pass current through a specific distance of human flesh to maximize the amount of pain from the same amount of current.  Two red skin marks from electrodes per shock, times 30 shocks in a day, quickly adds up so that very soon electrodes will be placed over previous marks resulting in bloody scabs.  In these cases, the multiple patches of bloody scabs have nothing to do with staff failing to rotate electrodes after shocking students. Rather it exemplifies that the electric shocks approach were not appropriate for the student, and that other approaches should have been found.

Dr. Israel has previously compared the electric shock devices to bee stings. I vividly remember nearly getting the wind knocked out of me during training at JRC back in 2003 when (I was) permitted to test out the weakest of JRC’s electric shock devices on my own arm. That was no bee sting!

I have worked with a young lady who was so underweight while on electric shock devices that she had a feeding tube sewn into her stomach to feed her when she would not eat enough. Upstairs there was a photo of her on the wall near Dr. Matthew Israel’s office from when she first entered JRC, looking comparatively plump.

I have witnessed a student with autism getting shocked for sitting at his desk with his eyes closed for more than 15 seconds because his mother didn’t like the fact that he closed his eyes. I wondered what it might feel like for me to try to shut my eyes at night to go to sleep after I had been shocked several times during the day for closing my eyes! Initially in his behavioral plan, the student was shocked for closing his eyes while walking down the hallway with the reason that it was “health dangerous” to close one’s eyes while walking down a short carpeted hallway. 

Later, JRC added more and more places where this student would get shocked for closing his eyes. Students with autism characteristically see the world as over-stimulating and overwhelming. I saw a photograph of the student at a young age with his eyes closed while holding up a large fish on a fishing trip. I don’t believe students should be shocked for having autism.

Besides shocking a student for the behavior of “closing eyes” while sitting at one’s desk for more than 15 seconds, or while walking down the hallway, shocking students for reacting to their classmates getting shocked, or shocking a student with all four limbs tied to a restraint chair while a staff violently attacked the student with a plastic knife to teach him a lesson, there were many other behaviors for which students were shocked that felt absolutely wrong to me. Students during my time at JRC were shocked for tearing a paper cup or Kleenex while sitting and watching television during their break, shocked for standing up and raising a hand and asking to go to the bathroom, shocked for pulling apart a loose thread, shocked for going to the bathroom in one’s clothes after signing that they need to use the bathroom for over two hours, shocking a blind, nonverbal girl with cerebral palsy for making a soft moaning sound in an effort to communicate and also shocking her for holding a staff’s hand, to name a few examples of many.

I am still unaware of even one study done that demonstrates that student behaviors remain “changed” after leaving JRC, once off the shock devices.

I was told repeatedly as a staff member at JRC that not only were these student behavior plans permitted by the judge, but some of the plans were ordered by the judge. Looking back, I question what the judge knew. Certainly JRC had a huge lack of oversight and it seemed that there was inadequate protection for the students.

On more than one occasion, I remember arriving to work and being surprised by drastic changes to individual student plans, where many behaviors for which a student would be shocked were eliminated from the student’s plan or else moved to a “minor” category for which the student would not be shocked. I remember being told by a student’s case manager that the behavior plans were changed because the student had an upcoming court date to prepare for. I do not believe that the judges were given the full picture of what they were approving when approving electric shocks on students.

After looking back, and to summarize some of the atrocities I witnessed and participated in while working at JRC, it is difficult for me to understand how I could have done something so cruel to other human beings. No doubt I was operating on misinformation, and misled to believe many of the same arguments that I hear parents arguing today. I truly believed that JRC was the only school that could help this population of students without the use of psychiatric drugs that turned children into zombies and ruined their livers.

Some children, not all, do respond to the threat of pain as long as they are strapped up to electric shock devices. But it is my strong opinion that JRC used electric shocks for many behaviors when other alternatives were available, and to the exclusion of more effective treatments. Psychologists leaving JRC told me that they had other treatments based on real research in established psychological journals that they wanted to use, but they were not allowed to use those other methods because Dr. Israel favored exclusively the use of electric shocks. 

Dr. Israel was out to prove the power of his electric shock devices, and in doing so, somewhere along the line the shock devices must have become more important to him than individual students. It is my opinion, as a former JRC teacher who later worked at another school serving a very similar student population as the JRC students with autism, that NO shocks are necessary to control student behaviors at JRC. 

If I was given the opportunity, I would sincerely apologize to each and every student I shocked at JRC. I certainly applaud and many others who have worked so diligently to end what I consider to be torture. Torture that is allowed and exists only in Canton, Massachusetts.

 

 
Jay Rosenthal November 06, 2011 at 04:38 AM
As a successful student of psychology at Mitchell College in New London, CT and having been through two different aversive free, psychotherapeutic based residential treatment centers (Andrus Children's Center in Yonkers,NY and The Learning Clinic in Brooklyn, CT), I have seen that benefits can be attained- even with the most troubling of cases. At JRC, the students appear to be treated as subjects of behavior instead of actual human beings. The students live in fear and could develop both psychological and physiological ailments later in life. Just because the behavior has ceased to exist does not mean the problem itself has also ceased to exist.
Donna Downing November 06, 2011 at 11:47 PM
Why cannot the US government ban shock treatments? Even Amnesty International has condemned this institution and it's practices. Continue to write congress to tell them to outlaw shock treatment, seclusion, and greatly limit restraint except in an emergency in all settings where people live and learn. Learn from those with autism their needs and how to assist them to successful lives ON THEIR TERMS!
Linda Rammler November 07, 2011 at 10:45 AM
All I can say, after many years of futile action as a member of various groups trying to close JRC/BRI, is that these revelations unfortunately are no surprise. EVERYONE -- from certain state representatives who parade their family members around the MA state house while they are getting shocked, to the Nazi-like suits that defend the practices publicly, to the parents who refuse to listen to truly evidence-based alternatives in the form of positive behavior supports -- should be held criminally accountable for these atrocities. War crimes with no war, except against the most vulnerable members of our society (yes, they ARE members) whose behaviors are merely indicative of the misery that exists when one cannot communicate, cannot have typical human relationships, and are abandoned and clearly not loved or respected at this horrid place.
VioletYoshi December 04, 2011 at 04:18 AM
I don't know really what to say. This center is like a horror film. The kid having a plastic knife held in his mouth while being restrained is like Saw or Hostel. If you ask me, the mom who said her son should be shocked for closing his eyes, if Jigsaw from the Saw films was real, I think he should rig up a torture machine that shocks her whenever she closes her eyes.
Anon January 31, 2012 at 03:07 AM
We have been watching the ongoing mistreatment of these children and young adults. Such atrocities will not go unnoticed. http://piratepad.net/gIdr9ZQ9SR
George Deabold February 22, 2012 at 07:33 PM
Will this place ever be shut down ??? http://www.myfoxboston.com/dpp/news/undercover/teen-tied-and-shocked-for-hours-mom-calls-it-torture-20120219
Pam March 01, 2012 at 02:32 PM
Wow. Thank you so much for posting this. I was actually unaware about this place at first and didn't know much about it when I applied for a position with them through an ad they had on an employment website. I was contacted via email on Monday to come in for an interview. The thing that started to give me a strange vibe was that they have an "open interview process", that I could just come in anytime mon-fri, between 9-3.... This isn't really typical for any professional establishment. Just seemed to desperate for help. When I emailed the guy for mor info, I never got a response. I also wondered why they had lots of positions open online, full time , part time, all sorts of availabiliities, without any real detailed description about the position, and they were pretty basic requirements. Of course looking at their website serves no justice. So today, before deciding whether I would actually try to go in for an interview today, I finally googled this place, and wow. Aside from this article fom 2011, there was even a piece done Monday by fox about this place of horrors; the day I was contacted! I'm so glad I didn't get roped into becoming a part of this horrific place after reading all these stories about it. I really need another job in the field of psychology that I love and studied for, but I am not willing to put my morals aside. What they are doing is WRONG and INEFFECTIVE and I hope this place is shut down.
DL Wald April 09, 2012 at 08:46 PM
Thank you for posting this. I am a former employee as well (end of 1999).. I lasted 4 months (approx).. I am still horrified at some of the stuff I saw, which is a big part of the reason I quit. I quit the day after i was required to give a skin shock
George Deabold April 10, 2012 at 04:26 AM
DL Wald ,please give me a call Iwould like to talk to you about the center George Deabold Educational Advocate 631) 383 - 6724
Lee Tilson May 05, 2012 at 11:21 PM
Perhaps it is time to act. I am embarrassed to say that I just became aware of this story. I want to do what I can to help. Feel free to contact me at peoplematter@gmx.com. Here is my blog piece from earlier today on this matter. http://www.rethinkingpatientsafety.com/my-blog/2012/05/does-never-again-mean-anything-learning-from-extreme-examples.html I am sorry to become aware of this so late. It is time for all of us to say NEVER AGAIN to the electroshock torture of children with disabilities. I hope you will join me. I hope to hear from you.
Lee Tilson May 05, 2012 at 11:54 PM
We must stop the torture of innocent children. After this is shut down, we need to understand why and how humans are seduced into evil, and why it took so long to shut this down. What is wrong our species? Why didn't we learn from Nazi Germany? While I am sure that there are many good things one can say about the staff, and some of the wonderful things they have done as human beings, this must stop now. We cannot allow the torture children. I remember my surprise when I learned that a German friend was seven when Hitler came to power. Because he passed his nose measurement, he was sent to a Nazi youth camp instead of a concentration camp. Seven years old. He never had a chance. He was one of the kindest most decent people I have ever met. Still, he was intellectually seduced into becoming a Nazi. If he was alive, my German friend would be loudly insisting that you cannot allow the torture of innocent children. He knows where it leads. He was there. And it does not matter how many virtues the staff have, or what their reasoning is. You don't torture innocent children. You just don't do it. It really is that simple. Please join me. Together we must stop this evil. http://bit.ly/IQdzq6 Feel free to contact me at peoplematter@gmx.com Lee Tilson Detroit
catherine thompson May 08, 2012 at 02:39 PM
I left a comment an hour ago, it didnt post...I was trying to type through the tears after reading this article. This is horrific. I am sick to my stomach. This place should be shut down! I came to this area 11 yrs ago, and i tried to get a job at this place. I tried twice as a matter of fact, both times they did not hire me. Now i know why! I told them i had an autistic child. If i ever ever seen this i would take what ever punishment they put forth. I would have taken video and sent it straight to 4 , 5and 7 at six and eleven.My son is 34 now and is doing well.This is just too much to take. Those poor children, I cant stop crying after reading this. This is unforgivable! I will sign any petition, and have everyone i know to sign as well! Catherine Thompson Anderson. Canton, Ma.
Danielle Ciccone May 09, 2012 at 12:37 AM
OCCUPY JUDGE ROTENBERG CENTER JUNE 2 2012 STOP THE TORTURE If it is not acceptable for the general population is is not acceptable for the disabled.
Tori May 09, 2012 at 07:40 PM
I would rather be homeless and starving to death than to ever do any of this to a living being. I would rather shock myself than ever do that to anyone. I am appalled at the people who work there as well as the people who worked there for any period of time. How could you ever think that torturing a poor innocent child or any person is right? Shocking someone for any reason, causing any kind of physical pain INTENTIONALLY makes you a monster. I don't care if you only did it once. How could you not have the integrity to walk away immediately?! How in the world is anyone SICK and TWISTED enough to believe they are helping by doing this? You have helped ruin these children's lives forever. If nightmares and nervous ticks are all you got from abusing these children for years, then you got off way too easy.
A. C. May 12, 2012 at 12:09 AM
I just read about your friend who was sent to a Hitler Youth camp instead of a concentration camp BECAUSE HE PASSED HIS NOSE MEASUREMENT and was brainwashed into evil despite having such a kind and decent personality. That is deeply disturbing because it gives evidence that there is evil in us all, like a chronic disease that can be subdued but never cured! It seems to be a disease we were born with as humankind, and you are right, it is MIND-BOGGLING because not only is it so horrifiying and deeply and ABSOLUTELY SICKENING, I cannot understand why we are born with this disease. Nazi Germany was not the first example of the disease attacking and it obviously is not the last. If a few people had done it, instead of the overwhelming majority with but just a few exceptions (I am grateful to type the latter phrase), then it would be more understandable, but this does not seem to make any sense and it scares me. Thank you SO MUCH for sharing this information, you are right, we HAVE TO UNDERSTAND THIS DISEASE SO WE CAN CURE IT. If the reply button does not show up here I will post another comment on this page to which you can reply regarding this. I AM INDESCRIBABLY GRATEFUL FOR HEROES LIKE YOU IN SUCH AN EVIL, DISGUSTING, F***ED-UP WORLD (my civilized vocabulary is insuffient to describe this).
Jennifer Sharpe May 12, 2012 at 05:05 AM
Gee lucky you found out, because once you are hired, you feel you have to do things to keep your job. Good luck with finding a job with a place with ethics.
Jennifer Sharpe May 12, 2012 at 05:07 AM
Good on you for quitting. We need to end this place.
Jennifer Sharpe May 12, 2012 at 05:08 AM
I would come but I live in Australia. I hope you have a good turn out. I hate how they justify why they do it and still think they are in the right. People power will show them it is not ok.
Jennifer Sharpe May 12, 2012 at 05:10 AM
My son is Aspergers, and I would go in and shock anyone who tried to do this to my son or punch them out. It is torture and they are the most vulnerable members of our society. I can not believe this is a modern day allowable practice. Appalled.
Jennifer Sharpe May 12, 2012 at 05:12 AM
What else can we do to shut this place down. If you have any ideas apart from signing the petition at change.org then please tell us, we all want to do something to stop it.
Jennifer Sharpe May 12, 2012 at 05:13 AM
Or if not imprisonment then at least strip them of their medical licences and stop them touching another patient or student ever again.
A. C. May 13, 2012 at 03:36 PM
TO LEE TILSON: You can reply to this comment regarding what I wrote earlier. And also I would go to the Occupy JRC protest but I don't live in the US. The fact that people know about this (including the US Department of Justice and the United Nations) yet it is still going on, I don't even know what to say about that. I want to thank everyone who is fighting to stop this; WE ARE NOT ALONE AND WE WILL CONQUER!
Lee Tilson May 13, 2012 at 03:49 PM
To: A.C. - There is no "reply" button. Kindly e mail me is you want a response.
catherine thompson May 13, 2012 at 04:01 PM
I will help in any way i can, we need to picket in front of the place if possible!
Ryan S May 16, 2012 at 03:44 PM
http://www.judgerc.org/responsetoblogs.pdf
Lee Tilson May 16, 2012 at 03:48 PM
To: Ryguytpt Do you agree that torture is immoral? Lee Tilson http://bit.ly/JvF3aZ To: Ryguytpt 1 minute ago http://www.judgerc.org/responsetoblogs.pdf
GL June 05, 2012 at 02:15 PM
If even half of this were true it is an atrocity of the treatment of the students. The knife held to the boy strapped in the chair, that would have been terribly confusing to him. Autism hears things literal. This boy would have thought they wanted and answer to their question and would have thought any answer would have been the correct thing to do cos all they asked was “Do you want to swallow a knife?” Yes or no right? But they continued it for weeks every day. The boy would have been none the wiser at the end of it on why it even happened in the 1st place. So sad. I can't believe they don't know the basics of what autism even is at JRC. To be shocked for tapping my pen on a desk or doing scribbles on paper if I'm a little bored...they get the equivalent to that but they have to do those things to feel safe or calm. To force autism to back down and box it up is causing an explosive to form in the child. They need an outlet for their energy and over sensitivities. That shock treatment harms more than most will ever see or know.
REAL HUMAN BEING June 15, 2012 at 05:29 AM
How is it legal to "treat at PT" with shock TX's but our sexual predators, violent offenders and drunk drivers get more compassion from the State/Government???? I think maybe a JRC for child predators, and violent criminals (repeat offenders) would be great candidates for these seemingly experimental TX's... Just saying
Freedom Lauralee Conklin March 22, 2013 at 06:57 PM
MAKE A FACEBOOK PAGE FOR THAT AND SHARE IT, AND ALSO SIGN IT UP ON CHANGE.ORG .
mary November 16, 2013 at 01:38 PM
Autism Speaks reserved a special table for the JRC as a resource for autistic people and their families at a recent Walk for Autism.....I suppose the Autism Speaks fundraising/social marketing guy Mark Sirkin "forgot" his official statement re the JRC's use of torture what with all the fundraising they're involved with?

Boards

More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something